Wednesday, March 18, 2009

We All Carry

I remember around this time last year posting many questions, sometimes writing exclusively in question form. When I say a year ago I mean the Jewish year. I looked back at March '08 and found wishes for a Good Purim in the comments on March 16th. That post was a short one that garnered comments that morhed into dialogue. It's cool when that happens. I recall that around Pesach I was heavy into the questions, so I'll look a month ahead. The post that I found was this one, and since I believe nothing is by accident I will link to that post (besides, I feel like it).

I just arrived home recently. I decided to ask the grocery to deliver, rather than schlepping for a change. Several people said nice things to me today and I hope, and think, vice versa. A colleague that was able to made some copies for me. And yet. One person was snippy to me early in the morning and I've been carrying it all day.

My dear friend Bin once told me that he remembered a story he heard in college from Dr. Taubes. An Oriental Sage was walking with some students when they reached a river. The water was low and they were about to walk through it when they noticed a young woman hesitating at the shore. The elder offered to carry the woman across, an offer she accepted. That evening one of his more nervy students asked the teacher how he could carry this attractive woman on his shoulders; did it not affect him negatively? The wise man replied, "I put her down hours ago, are you still carrying her?"

Carrying things is a tricky business. I remember during what was simply called the Lebanon War in the early eighties, reading a Time magazine cover story about Ariel Sharon, while I spent a week or so living with my grandfather, while my grandmother recuperated in the hospital from a heart attack (may their neshamot both have aliyot and may they have much nachas from the good they perpetuated in this world). Sharon said that he was not the type to ever look back, he sounded quite proud about this. It's a type. I wonder what it's like.

I perused April '08. Still no sign of question. The first post I linked to was a short poem with a thread of comments. (There were no comments by me. Maybe I just wanted that thread to play out without my involvement. I facilitated from the side. Still, I feel a bit badly. I do generally try to reply to comments. This is a blog etiquette that I learned early on from fellow blogger, and writer of A Stranger Among Us, Robert Avrech. He always responds to comments of his readers. There's another approach, which is that rather than replying on your own site in your own comments the nicest thing to do for a fellow blogger who commented on your post is to visit their site and, if it's feasible, to leave a comment for them too. Anne, Therapy Doc, and Jack are particularly good at this M.O. Some bloggers, including some of the ones just mentioned, do both.

I didn't yet find in April '08 those question posts that I've been thinking about. I did find a short poem called Histakel, with one comment - sort of.

2 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Try from '08, April 10th, 13th, 16th, 25th, and 28th.

March 18, 2009 at 10:52 PM  
Blogger rabbi neil fleischmann said...

Thanks Anon. I recall a friend of mine not noticing that I was writin so many questions but noticing that, as he put it, my words during that time sounded even more piercing and thoughtful than usual. I remember the post of the 25th most vividly of all, sitting in a wonderland - "and loving it." It feels like a few minutes ago that I wrote the post.

Thanks for pointing out each of these. The power of questions is amazing, isn't it?

Here's that one, for thse who might find there way into this rabbit hole:

Not Missing The Flatlands

What was Yaakov's nature? Was he an Ish Tam, as he's described as a boy, sitting with his face buried in a book? When he meets Lavan and says he's a brother, Chazal hear him saying; "I'll play ball however you want. You want to shoot straight, fine. You want to play crooked with me, then I'll be playing you move for move. Could it be there was a process Yaakov went through? How would you describe his process?

Do you think that in life we have to go through a process, similar to the one Yaakov did? Could it be that the dealings with Yaakov and Lavan were necessary to make him who he was? To make the Jewish People who we are as a group and as individuals?

Did you ever notice that Lavan means white and Edom means red? What can we glean from this about different types of adversaries? What do you think of the saying "man's inhumanity against man?"

When my friend Seth Berman left the theater with his father, as a kid, after seeing Bang The Drum Slowly his father turned to him. Then he said, "that move was about man's inhumanity against man." Sounds right.

Can someone small or old or feeble still act in an inhumane way? Are big and loud and tough talkers more dangerous or just more scary (or neither) (or both)? Did you ever meet someone with a tough style and find that they're very compassionate? Did you ever encounter someone who proves to be dangerous who smiles and speaks in terms of endearments?

I sit on a balcony of an suburban looking home built incongruously at the edge of the camp grounds that are hosting me this week. The days here have been rich. My time here always reminds me of Magic Mountain. It's about a man who goes to visit a sanatorium and gets taken in by the life and world apart. As Wikipedia puts it: "In the opening chapter, Hans is symbolically transported away from the familiar life and mundane obligations he has known, in what he later learns to call "the flatlands", to the rarefied mountain air and introspective little world of the sanatorium."

March 18, 2009 at 11:20 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home